Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

A Slice of Paradise

  • $$$$
  • Pizza
  • 24458 Overseas Hwy, Summerland Key 33042 24.661444 -81.450877
  • (At Caribbean Dr)
  • click map to interact
  • (305) 744-9718
  • 0
  • Profile & Reviews

User Ratings (Based on 26 reviews)

avg-come back to15
Food 3 Value 2_5
Service 3 Atmosphere 2

Other Restaurant Info

(305) 744-9718
Major Credit Cards
Mon-Fri: 11am-9pm Sat-Sun: 11am-11pm
Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Delivery, Good for Groups, Outdoor Seating, Take Out

User Reviews

  • A Slice of Paradise

    Posted by Sandie on 2015-05-06

    Awesome Greek Salad

    I use to order pizza on Tuesday's, but now "doctor" up my Amy's organic on the grill. In addition, I order a Greek salad every week, the serving size is extremely generous and everything is fresh. My only complaint, sorry, but, the walls in the buildi

  • A Slice of Paradise

    Posted by Frank on 2015-03-27

    Better than expected....

    Had a craving for pizza. Took a shot at paradise pizza it was on my way. Only two tables, nothing to look at but the pizza was good-had a vegie one. Did not scrimp on veggies or sauce and it was cooked just fine. I think I will go there again-maybe with

  • A Slice of Paradise

    Posted by Anders on 2015-01-21

    Tasty snack

    After moving down here a few months ago I have to say this is hands down my favorite local pizza place! They do forget my ranch every time though......BUT THE PIZZA is good enough I will continue to order it

  • A Slice of Paradise

    Posted by john ruggieri on 2015-01-20

    great pizza

    Had the pizza slices. Excellent crust and toppings.

  • A Slice of Paradise

    Posted by NomNom on 2014-08-01

    Will be Back

    I just moved to the Keys two months ago and I am not a fan of seafood. I wanted to find a good pizza place nearby. I have tried a few places and wasn't impressed but finally found quality pizza from Slice of Paradise! My kids also really loved their chick

  • A Slice of Paradise

    Posted by Spyder Lady on 2014-07-08


    We ordered Chicken Fingers and ate it right there in the restaurant on July 5, 2014. They were delicious and the price was right for the amount that was given. I figured we would have gotten 2-3, but no, they gave us 5. That was way more than I could e

  • A Slice of Paradise

    Posted by lindsay on 2013-10-21


    I had ordered a philly cheese steak no mushrooms no peppers extra onions & black olives and Bbq chips from slice of paradise & it was fantastic! Everything I ordered was delived hot, fresh, correct & before given time. The delivery driver was awesome! Ver

  • A Slice of Paradise

    Posted by Stephen Sparrow on 2013-10-21

    Always Good and Tasty

    Been getting pizza delivered almost every Tuesday. Pie always delivered hot and fresh, Have only had one wrong order and received a free pizza next time we ordered, not sure about the other negative reports, maybe they are use to big company fake pizzas n

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.