Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Bagel Island Cafe

In the Winn Dixie Shopping Center
  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Bagels
  • 205 Key Deer Blvd, Big Pine Key FL33043 24.672579 -81.358051
  • (MM 30)
  • (305) 872-9912
  • 0

Bagels & Breads


Plain, Poppy, Sesame, Garlic, Pumpernickel, Salt, Everything, Egg, Honey Wheat with Oats, Honey Wheat Cranberry, Sun-dried Tomato, Spinach-herb, Cinnamon-raisin, Blueberry, and Key Lime (In Season).

Single Bagel    .75
Half-dozen Bagels    3.90
Dozen Bagels    7.50

Bagels or Bread

with the following toppings:

Butter    .95
Butter and Jelly, Honey    1.50
Peanut Butter and Jelly    1.95
Plain Cream Cheese    1.95
Flavored Cream Cheese    2.35
Plain Low-fat Cream Cheese    2.25
Flavored Low-fat Cream Cheese    2.50
Nova-lox Spread    3.82
Low-fat Nova-lox Spread    4.22
Anything On a Croissant   Add 1.00

Cream Cheese Flavors

Scallion & Chive    
All Flavors Are Available In Low-fat

Cream Cheese Containers To Go

Plain Cream Cheese S 1.75M 3.00L 6.00
Flavored Cream Cheese S 2.00M 3.60L 6.50
Plain Low-fat Cream Cheese S 2.00M 3.50L 6.50
Flavored Low-fat Cream Cheese S 2.50M 3.75L 7.00
Nova-lox Cream Cheese S 3.00M 5.00L 9.50
Low-fat Nova-lox Cream Cheese S 3.50M 5.50L 9.75


Pastries Are Baked Fresh Each Morning!

Cinnamon Rolls    1.59
Cheese, Raspberry, or Blueberry Danish    1.59
Strawberry Cream Croissant    1.59
Apple Croissant    1.59
Chocolate Croissant    1.59
Plain Croissant    1.59
Muffins, Cookies, Macaroons   As Priced 
Day-old-bagel    2.50
Bagel Chips    2.50



One Egg with Hash Browns and Choice of Toast   3.25
Two Eggs with Hash Browns and Choice of Toast   3.75

Atkins Diet

Three Eggs choice of Ham, Bacon or Sausage, and a slice of cheese and tomato   4.25

French Toast

Just ask for cinnamon French toast!

One Waffle Eggo Waffles Upon Request   1.75
Two Waffles Eggo Waffles Upon Request   2.75
Add Bacon, Ham or Sausage   Add 1.25

Bagel or Bread

Choose from the following fillings:

One Egg    2.25
Cheese    2.25
One Egg and Cheese    2.65
Bacon, Ham, or Sausage    2.65
One Egg, Bacon, Ham or Sausage    2.80
One Egg, Cheese, Bacon, Ham or Sausage    3.00
Anything On a Croissant   Add 1.00
Let us know if you want Butter, Mayo, Salt, Pepper, or Dressings.

Side Orders

Extra Lettuce, Tomato, and Onion    .50
Oatmeal Ask for Cinnamon   2.00
Hash Browns    1.50
Toast with Butter   1.00
Extra Ham, Bacon or Sausage    1.25
Eggs   Each 1.00
Frozen Strawberries   Add 1.00



Daily Lunch Special Sub with Can of Soda and Bag of Chips...4.63


Choice of Toppings: Sandwiches are served on your choice of Bagel, Bread, or Sub roll. All Sandwiches include a choice of Toppings:

Bagel    4.50
Bread Rye, White or Wheat   4.50
Sub Roll   Half 3.75Whole 6.75
Croissant   Add 1.00
Roast Beef Sandwich   Add .50
Roast Beef Sub   Add 1.00
Cuban Mix Sub   Add 1.00
Grilled Cheese American, Swiss, Provolone, or Cheddar   3.25
with Bacon and Tomato  Add 1.00
Lox With Lettuce, Tomato, Capers, Onion and choice of Cream Cheese   5.70
BLT Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato and Mayo   3.50
Grilled Reuben Pastrami, Sauerkraut, Swiss Cheese, and Thousand Island Dressing   5.50
Cuban Mixed, not pressed   5.50
Ny Club Turkey, Choice of Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Bacon and Mayo on two pieces of toast   5.50
The Ultimate Beach Bill Sesame Bagel, Lettuce, Italian Dressing, and choice of Cheese   2.14
Italian Ham, Salami, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Provolone cheese, Italian Dressing, Italian Seasoning, Jalapenos, or Banana Peppers   5.50
The Hawaiian Holly Toasted Plain Bagel, Ham, Pineapple, Choice of Cheese. This sandwich is HOT   4.12
Manatee Munchie Sun-dried tomato bagel, tomato, lettuce and veggie cream cheese   2.75
Sandwiches are served on your choice of Bagel, Bread, or Sub roll.

Meat Choices

Chicken Salad    
Tuna Salad    
Egg Salad    
Cuban Mix    
Roast Beef    

Cheese Choices



Red Onion    
Green Pepper    
Banana Peppers    
Deli Mustard    
Yellow Mustard    
Oil & Vinegar    

Deli Sandwich Side Orders

Extra Meat add an extra 3oz of your meat choice  Add 1.25
Extra Cheese  (Add 6 inch or Sandwich) .50 (Add 12 inch) 1.00
Extra Lettuce, Tomato, or Onion  (Add 6 inch or Sandwich) .50 (12 inch Add) 1.00
Side Salad    2.25


Chef Salad Ham, Turkey, Choice of Two Cheeses, Romaine & Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, and Banana peppers or Jalapenos   6.50
Cobb Salad Turkey, Bacon, Egg, Tomato, Diced Onion, Cucumbers, Romaine & Iceberg Lettuce, and Bleu Cheese Dressing on the side   6.50
Garden Salad Romaine & Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, Choice of Cheese   4.50
Tuna Salad Garden Salad with a scoop of Tuna Salad on top (contains mayo)   5.50
Chicken Salad Garden Salad with a scoop of Chicken Salad on top (contains mayo)   5.50
Egg Salad Garden Salad with a scoop of Egg Salad on top (contains mayo)   5.25
Salad Dressings: Thousand Island, French, Blue Cheese, Ranch, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Oil & Vinegar, Italian, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Mango Poppy, and Key Lime Caesar *Some Dressings are Available in Low-Fat-- Please Ask.

Salad Side Orders

Extra Meat    1.25
Extra Cheese    .50
Extra Lettuce, Tomato, or Onion   Each .50
To-go Container of Tuna, Egg, or Chicken Salad    2.25
Side Salad    2.25



All Coffees and Teas Are Available Hot or Iced. Flavored Coffees Vary. Please Ask for Daily Fresh-brewed Flavors.


Small / Large

Regular, Decaf Coffee   1.25 1.50
Daily Flavored Coffee   1.50 1.75
Cappuccino   2.75 3.25
Flavored Cappuccino   3.00 3.50
Cafe con Leche   2.25 2.75
Latte   2.75 3.25
Flavored Latte   3.00 3.50
Espresso Shots Buchl  1.20 2.00
Americano   2.00 2.50
Hot Teas Green, Earl Grey, Regular & Constant Comment  1.25 1.50
Chai Tea   1.25 2.50
Unsweetened Iced Tea   1.29 1.59
Choose whole, 2%, 1%, or SOY MILK in your coffee, cappuccino, or latte. *Add Flavoring or Flavored Creamer.............add $0.50

Flavored Creamer

Hazelnut   Add .50
Butter Pecan   Add .50
Irish Cream   Add .50
French Vanilla   Add .50
Chocolate   Add .50
Amaretto   Add .50
Caramel *   Add .50
Irish Cream*   Add .50
Chocolate Biscotti *   Add .50
Vanilla *   Add .50
Orgeat Almond *   Add .50

Flavored Syrups

Hazelnut *   Add .50
Creme Menthe*   Add .50
Amaretto*   Add .50
Peppermint *   Add .50
White Chocolate Bianco *   Add .50

Sugar Free Syrups


Frozen Coffee Coolada

Espresso    3.35
Chocolate Mocha, Coffee, Vanilla    3.35

Non-Coffee Drinks

Non-Coffee Cooladas Cookies & Cream, Cotton Candy, and Strawberry   3.35
Sports Drinks, Gatorade, Juices, Snapple, Flavored Water    1.50
Bottled Water, Yoohoo Drink    1.25
Can Soda    1.00
Glass of Milk 1% or Whole   1.25
Add Strawberry or Chocolate Syrup to Your Milk *   Add .50
Soy Milk Regular or Vanilla   1.25


Peach, Strawberry, Mango-Guava, Pina Colada  (Add Fresh Banana to any add) .50Small 3.25 Large 3.75
Peach, Strawberry    


Vanilla, Strawberry, Chocolate, Butterscotch, Caramel  Small 2.75 Large 3.50
Add Protein, M&Ms, or Oreos   Add 1.00


Bagel Island Cafe
205 Key Deer Blvd
MM 30
(305) 872-9912
© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.