Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Bentley's Restaurant

  • $$$$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • American (Traditional)
  • 82779 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada FL33036 24.928191 -80.623132
  • (At De Leon Ave)
  • click map to interact
  • (305) 664-9094
  • 0


Daily Specials

Ask Your Server About Our Daily Specials Board

Mondays prime rib, certified angus beef   
Tuesday bubba gump shrimp   
Wednesday "the big one". a huge assortment of fresh seafood   
Thursdays steak night. certified angus beef, filet or strip   
Fridays surf & turf   
Saturdays lobster night   
Sundays chef's choice   


Lobster Shrimp And Crab Cake    9.95
Seafood Spinach Dip    8.95
Calamari    8.95
Gator Tail    9.95
Crabmeat Balls    10.95
Yellow Fin Tuna Wasabi    12.95
St Louis BBQ Ribs    9.95
Escargot Capriccio    10.95
Homemade Conch Fritters    8.95
Bentley's Famous Chicken Wings  (10) 8.95(20) 14.95
Bentley's Shrimp Cocktail    11.95
Clams  (half doz) 6.95(doz.) 11.95
Oysters  (half doz) 6.95(doz.) 11.95
Peel & Eat Shrimp   (4oz) 7.95(8oz) 12.95
Steamed Clams Or Oysters   (doz.) 11.95
Oysters Moscovite fresh oysters topped with sour cream, horseradish sauce and caviar   12.95
Oysters Rockefeller Supreme fresh oysters topped with shrimp, crabmeat, artichokes, cream of spinach and baked with jack cheese   12.95
Crazy Upside Down Oysters fresh oysters topped with minced onions, hot medium or mild sauce, crackers and jack cheese   12.95

Homemade Soups

Cup $3.95 / Bowl $5.95

French Onion    
Bahamian Conch Chowder hot & spicy, just like the islands   


Caesar Salad     4.95
House Salad    5.95

House Specialties

All Dinners Include Caesar Salad And Choice Of Twice Baked Potato, French Fries, Baked Potato, Creamed Spinach Or Corn-On-The-Cob.

House Favorite Cioppino  1/2 lobster, clams, shrimp, crab, scallops, mussels & dolphin sauteed in a spicy marinara garlic butter sauce with a splash of sherry served over linguini   31.95
Stuffed Yellowtail Supreme lightly breaded filet of fish on top of our homemade seafood stuffing topped with a lemon caper butter sauce   25.95
Dolphin In The Weeds  mahi-mahi lightly breaded & baked served over creamed spinach, shrimp, crab & artichoke heart stuffing    23.95
Grassy Key Lime Yellowtail fillet of fish baked with key lime juice & fresh herbs, topped with shrimp & asparagus & served on a bed of sauteed fresh spinach with lemon caper butter sauce on the side   25.95
Nutty-Crusted Dolphin filet of fish encrusted with fresh chopped nuts, then baked. served with a lemon caper butter sauce   23.95
Stuffed Shrimp six jumbo shrimp topped with a homemade seafood stuffing   18.95
Fried Shrimp eight shrimp lightly breaded & fried served with cocktail or tarter sauce   18.95
Broiled Scallops  large sea scallops cooked in garlic butter sauce with lemon & sherry, served over linguini on request   23.95
14oz Certified Angus Beef Strip Steak fresh cut daily and cooked to perfection   
Twin Filet Mignon Certified Angus Beef twin 5oz certified angus beef filets cooked to perfection   
St Louis BBQ Ribs full slab of barbecue ribs served with our special house bbq sauce   19.95
"Caribbean Jerk" Chicken lightly breaded & marinated in a blend of island spices served on a bed of fresh spinach with lemon caper butter sauce on the side   17.95
Blackened Chicken Aruba boneless breast of chicken dusted with cajun spices, pan sauteed in olive oil, topped with sauteed spinach, hearts of palm, portabella mushrooms & bearnaise sauce (available baked & served with lemon caper butter sauce)   18.95
Stone Crabs in season   
Alaskan King Crab    
Fresh Local Florida Lobster 1 1/4 or 2 lbs steamed to perfection   
Outta Hand Lobster steamed, topped with sauteed shrimp, scallops, mushrooms, scallion, spinach, cashews & lemon caper butter sauce add   5.00
Surf & Turf your choice of certified angus beef brand steak plus your choice of seafood   

We Will Cook Your Catch!

Try Any Of Our Delightful Toppings Including:

Outta Hand    
In The Weeds    
Tropical Coconut    
Stuffed Supreme    

A La Carte

4oz $8.95 / 8oz $14.95.

Louisiana Spicy Shrimp baked with your choice of hot, medium or mild louisiana sauce.   
over linguini add   1.00
Garlic Shrimp tender shrimp baked in garlic butter   
over linguini add   1.00


All Served On A Roll With Lettuce, Tomato, And Onion, Cole Slaw And French Fries.

Lobster, Shrimp, Crabcake Sandwich lightly deep fried to a golden brown   12.95
Fish Sandwich a large filet of fish fried in a special batter.   10.95
Bentley's Fish Sandwich fried and topped with monterey jack cheese and served with a fresh dill mayonnaise sauce   12.95
Chicken Sandwich boneless breast of chicken, fried and served with fresh dill mayonnaise sauce   10.95


All Served On A Roll With Lettuce, Tomato, And Onion, Cole Slaw And French Fries.

Burger    9.95
Cheeseburger    10.95
Cajun Cheeseburger choice of american, monterey jack, swiss or provolone.   12.95
All Burgers Are Made With A Half Pound Of Ground Certified Angus Beef

Side Orders

French Fries    2.50
Baked Potato    2.50
Twice Baked Potato    3.50
Corn The Cob    2.50
Creamed Spinach    2.50
Garlic Bread    2.50
Spaghetti Marinara    3.95
Bentley's Drunken Sweet Potato    4.25


Annie's Homemade Key Lime Pie    5.50
Bentley's Banana Foster  sm 8.95lg 12.95
Reese's Peanut Butter Pie    6.95
Nutty Drunken Ice Cream  sm 8.95lg 12.95


Early Bird Menu

Served 4-6pm

Broiled Or Baked Dolphin fresh dolphin filet browned with lemon, butter and wine or baked with seasoned bread crumbs.   19.95
Dolphin In The Weeds lightly breaded and baked then placed on top of creamed spinach with shrimp, crab and artichokes.   21.95
Blackened Dolphin cooked in olive oil with cajun spices.   20.95
Nutty Dolphin filet of fish encrusted with fresh chopped nuts, then baked. served with a lemon caper butter sauce.   21.95
Louisiana Spicy Shrimp have them your way hot, medium, mild or in garlic butter over linguini.   17.95
Mussels Marinara (when available) large mussels served over linguini, smothered with marinara sauce and our famous garlic bread.   17.95
Baked Boneless Chicken Breast roasted to a golden brown, then topped with a lemon caper sauce. also available blackened, or caribbean jerk.   17.95
St. Louis Style BBQ Ribs the full slab, in our special sauce, another bentley's tradition is back.   19.95
Lobster Or Shrimp Crab Cake deep fried to perfection, topped with a garlic herb butter sauce.   16.95
Stuffed Shrimp jumbo shrimp topped with our homemade stuffing.   17.95

Additional Nightly Specials

All Dinners Include

Caesar Salad    
Choice Of Potato    
Fresh Vegetable    
Tea Or Soda    


Annie's Key Lime Pie    
Vanilla Ice Cream    
Yellowtail May Be Substituted For $2 More


Little Bites For Little Bits

Ages Twelve And Under


Lobster, Shrimp Crabcake    9.95
Gator Tail breaded chunks sauteed in lemon garlic butter   9.95
Homemade Conch Fritters    8.95
4oz. Peel & Eat Shrimp    7.95
Bentley's Famous Chicken Wings hot, medium, mild (10) 8.95(20) 14.95

Soups & Salads

Soup Of The Day  cup 3.95bowl 5.95
House Salad    5.95
Caesar Salad    4.95

Burgers & Sandwiches

Served On A Roll With Lettuce And Tomato, Coleslaw And Choice Of Steak Fries Or Corn On The Cob

Hamburger    9.95
Cheeseburger    10.95
Cajun Cheeseburger    11.95
Jumbo Hot Dog    6.95
Fish Sandwich    10.95
Bentley's Fish Sandwich with monterey jack cheese & special sauce   12.95
Chicken Sandwich     10.95

Dinner Specials

Served With Coleslaw And Choice Of Steak Fries Or Corn On The Cob

Dolphin Fingers lightly breaded & deep fried to a golden brown   11.95
Chicken Fingers lightly breaded boneless chicken breast deep fried to a golden brown   9.95
Hoppin' Shrimp 8 shrimp, lightly breaded & deep fried to a golden brown   10.95
Lasagna served with garlic bread    8.95
Wranglin' Ribs baked in our special bbq sauce   11.95
JJ.'s Cowboy Steak angus strip steak prepared to your satisfaction   16.95
Spaghetti And Meatballs served with garlic bread   6.95


Bentley's Chocolate Sundae    6.95
Ice Cream    3.95
Reese's Peanut Butter Pie     6.95


Red Wines By The Glass

Cabernet Sauvignon

BV Coastal Estates, Cabernet Sauvignon, 2008, California    6.00
Robert Mondavi Winery, Napa Valley, Cabernet Sauvignon, 2007, Napa Valley    


Abbaye De Saint-Ferme, "Les Vignes Du Soir", 2006, Bordeaux    5.00
Blackstone Winery, Merlot, 2005, California    7.00

Pinot Noir

Mont Pellier, Pinot Noir, 2009, California    5.00


White Wines By The Glass


Tisdale, Chardonnay, 2008, California    5.00
Deloach Vineyards, Russian River, Chardonnay, 2008, Russian River, Sonoma    6.00
Kendall-Jackson "Vintners Reserve" Chardonnay, 2006, California    8.00

Sauvignon, Fume & Chein Blanc's

Marlborough Vineyards, Sacred Hill, Sauvignon Blanc, 2008, Marlborough, NZ    6.00

Pinot Grigio's & Pinot Gris

Bohemian Highway, Pinot Grigio, 2007, California    6.00

Riesling's & Gewurztraminer's

Hogue, Johannesburg Riesling, 2005, Columbia Valley    7.00

More Great Whites

Sutterhome, White Zinfandel, 2007, California    5.00


Bentley's Restaurant
82779 Overseas Hwy
At De Leon Ave
(305) 664-9094
© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.