Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Big John's Pizza Pasta & Subs

New York Style Pizza
  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Pizza, Sandwiches, Italian
  • 1103 Key Plaza, Key West FL33040 24.580441 -81.737738
  • (At Cypress Ave)
  • (305) 293-9576
  • 0
  • Profile & Reviews

User Ratings (Based on 4 reviews)

Food 1.6 Value 1.5
Service 1.9 Atmosphere 1.4

Other Restaurant Info

(305) 293-9576
Visa, MC, AmEx, Disc
Mon-Sat: 11am-11pm Sun: 12pm-10pm
Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Catering, Delivery, Kid Friendly, Lunch Special, Take Out

User Reviews

  • Big John's Pizza Pasta & Subs

    Posted by Kris on 07/21/2014


    This place used to be one of our favorite pizza joints, but the last few visits have been pretty disappointing. We decided we would give it one last try today and after today decided we will never EVER go back. The food was done insanely quick.. Almost too quick. We made jokes about how the food was cooked from a bag and soon realized we were probably correct! My 'salad' was nothing more than a huge pile of shredded iceberg lettuce and a 'to-go' packet of ranch dressing. My shrimp scampi had absolutely no seasoning. It was literally a bed of pasta laying in a massive pool of butter. The shrimp were super rubbery and tasted odd, which made me wonder if they were frozen and possibly freezer burnt. My son has the chicken strips which were probably the tastiest food at the table, but definitely tasted frozen and freezer burnt. My sister in law got fettuccine Alfredo and all I can say it wow! Her sauce looked like the gravy you put on your biscuits - very, very thick and clumpy. Her chicken was shockingly cut into perfect square cubes... The same square cubes on my brother's buffalo chicken pizza. Curious! We left about 85% of the food and paid entirely too much for such an unappetizing meal. I think it's one thing to find one person or maybe two that dislike some aspect of their meal, but when everyone at the table refuses to eat the food you have to question the quality of food.

  • Big John's Pizza Pasta & Subs

    Posted by Nancy on 10/05/2013

    Consistently inconsistent!

    Ordered a pep pie delivery...received a pie which was obviously a rescue! Crust was nice and crispy, cheese..dried up, sauce...non-existent, pepperoni, raw!

  • Big John's Pizza Pasta & Subs

    Posted by D on 02/26/2013

    Huge let down

    I order the meat pizza for delivery and was told 45 min. An hour and a half later i called to see if it was still coming and was told that it was on its way. I didn't get the pizza until 15 min after that. Also, I hadn't eaten all day, so any pizza would have been delicious, and still this pizza had cheap toppings and unappetizing sauce. I do not recommend to anyone!

  • Big John's Pizza Pasta & Subs

    Posted by DJJMama on 06/16/2010

    Good Stuff!

    I recently moved back to KW and was delighted this place had arrived since my departure. Delicious, fast, reasonable. Atmosphere reminded me of a NY pizzeria and when I ordered out, it arrived very fast, piping hot and de-lish! Stuffed pizza is huge and all other items I've tried are yummy :o) Definitely a speed dial on my phone!

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.