Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

City Hall Cafe

  • $$$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • American (Traditional)
  • 88507 Overseas Hwy, Tavernier FL33070 25.0287909 -80.4973119
  • (At Village St)
  • (305) 852-3354
  • 0


Growth Management

Add: ($3) - Chicken, Crab Cake; ($3.50) - Buffalo Chicken; ($5) - Mahi, shrimp; ($5.50) - Buffalo Shrimp.

Mixed Green Salad    6.99
Classic Caesar Salad    6.99
Spinach Salad    7.99
Greek Salad    9.29
Antipasto Salad    10.49
Chef Salad    10.49
Stuffed Tomato choose tuna salad or chicken salad   8.99
Salad Dressing: House Vinaigrette, Ranch, 1000 Island, Bleu Cheese, Parmesan Peppercorn, Honey Mustard.

Wrap Session

Add Fries, Potato Salad, Cole Slaw Or Pasta Salad For $1.29 Each

Chicken Caesar Wrap choose buffalo, thai, blackened or grilled   7.99
Shrimp Caesar Wrap choose buffalo, thai, blackened or grilled   9.49
Fresh Tuna Or Chicken Salad with lettuce, tomato & onion   7.99
Veggie Bird turkey with lettuce, tomato, onion, sprouts, peppers, cucumbers, provolone & cheddar   8.29
Veggie & Cheese with lettuce, tomato, onion sprouts, peppers, cucumbers, provolone & cheddar   7.99
Roast Beef & Smoked Gouda with lettuce, tomato, onion & horseradish sauce   8.49
Roast Turkey & Dill Havarti with sprouts, lettuce, tomato, onion & honey mustard   7.99
Sliced Turkey & Provolone with artichokes, lettuce, tomato & onion   8.29

Juvenile Department $4.75

12 & Under Only, Please

Grilled Cheese & Fries    
Hot Dog & Fries    
Chicken Fingers (3) & Fries    
Mozzarella Sticks & Fries    
Ham & American & Fries    

Planning Department

Fried Mozzarella breaded mozzarella served with marinara sauce   5.99
Chicken Fingers served with honey mustard   6.79
Buffalo Shrimp served with celery & blue cheese  (5) 9.99
Crab Cakes two crab cakes on mixed greens   8.99
French Fries    2.49
Onion Rings    4.29
Buffalo Wings choose mild, medium, hot, teriyaki, thai or bbq. served with celery & blue cheese (5) 6.99(10) 10.99
Homemade Soup Of The Day   bowl 3.99
Chili   bowl 4.50

Sub Divisions

Choose your bread: white or multigrain sub roll, kaiser roll, sliced white, wheat, french or rye / choose your cheese: american, swiss, havarti, provolone, smoked gouda, pepper jack or cheddar / Please specify: Mayo, mustard, oil & vinegar, lettuce, tomato, onion, banana peppers, jalapenos, pickles.

Italiana Combo    8.99
American Combo ham, turkey, roast beef & american   8.99
Roast Turkey    7.99
Roast Beef    8.49
Smoked Honey Ham    7.99
Turkey Club    8.99
Tuna Or Chicken Salad    7.99
Veggie & Cheese    7.99
Veggie Bird with turkey   8.99

Mayor's Vote

Extra Toppings ($0.79) - cheese, bacon, mushrooms, grilled peppers & onions

1/2 Lb. Hamburger    8.49
with cheese   9.29
Patty Melt burger with cheese & grilled onions on grilled rye   9.29
Cowboy Burger bbq sauce, onion rings & pepper jack cheese   10.29
Mahi Sandwich grilled, blackened or fried   10.99
Cheesesteak with grilled onions & peppers   9.99
Crab Cake Sandwich    9.99
French Dip    9.99
Grilled Rosemary Chicken with provolone   10.49
Eggplant Parmesan    9.29
Meatball Parmesan    9.29
Chicken Parmesan    9.99
Corned Beef, Turkey Or Pastrami Reuben with kraut, swiss & 1000 island on grilled rye   9.99
All Beef Hot Dog    5.99
with kraut   6.99
with chili & cheese   7.99
Cowboy Chicken Sandwich grilled chicken breast with bbq sauce, onion rings & pepper jack cheese   10.49
Mayor's Vote Items Served With Fries, Potato Salad, Cole Slaw Or Pasta Salad



Served After 5pm


Buffalo Shrimp    9.99
Crab Cakes over mixed greens   8.99
Mozzarella Sticks    5.99
Chicken Fingers    6.79
Fried Shrimp    9.99
Buffalo Wings medium, hot, thai, bbq or teriyaki (5) 6.99(10) 10.99
Soup Of The Day    3.99


Dinner Salad    4.00
Caesar Salad    6.99
with chicken   9.99
with shrimp   11.99
Greek Salad    9.29
Antipasto Salad    10.49

Pasta Selections

Served With Choice Of Soup, Dinner Salad Or Caesar Salad, And Bread

Kickin' Chicken blackened chicken served over penne pasta tossed in alfredo sauce   16.99
Spaghetti And Meatballs like mama used to make   11.99
Blackened Shrimp Alfredo mouth-watering blackened shrimp, pasta, and our delicious alfredo sauce   18.99
Shrimp Scampi succulent shrimp cooked in garlic, butter & white wine served over angel hair pasta   18.99
Pasta Aioli spaghetti tossed in olive oil, garlic, parmesan & fresh parsley   10.99
with chicken   16.99
with shrimp   18.99
Eggplant Parmesan breaded eggplant, marinara sauce & melted provolone served over pasta   12.99
Cappella D'Angeli fresh tomatoes, artichoke hearts, capers, sweet basil, garlic & olive oil tossed with angel hair   11.99
with chicken   16.99
with shrimp   18.99
Chicken Carbonara grilled chicken, bacon, peas, mushrooms and pasta tossed in a creamy sauce   17.99


Served With Choice Of, Dinner Salad Or Caesar Salad, Starch Of The Day, Vegetable, And Bread

Filet Mignon eight ounce hand-cut filet   24.99
12oz Hand-Cut New York Strip topped with burgundy-mushroom sauce and crispy fried onions   24.99
Cafe Chicken sauteed chicken breast topped with artichokes, mushrooms, capicola & capers, then smothered in provolone   17.99

Veal $18.99


Chicken $16.99



Fresh Catch Almondine almond encrusted fresh fish with lemon-butter sauce   17.99
Yenoz Ahi Tuna Filet sashimi-grade tuna served blackened, pepper-crusted, sesame-encrusted or teriyaki   21.99
Mahi-Mahi blackened, grilled oe fried   17.99
with crab stuffing   19.99
We Will Cook Your Catch $11.99 Per Person


Nightly Specials

Monday italian   
Tuesday mexican   
Wednesday comfort food   
Thursday mexican   
Friday chef's choice   
Saturday prime rib   
City Hall Cafe
88507 Overseas Hwy
At Village St
(305) 852-3354
© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.