Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Islamorada Fish Company

  • $$$$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Seafood
  • 81532 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada FL33036 24.9144966 -80.6403999
  • (Btwn Matecumbe & Jerome Ave)
  • (305) 664-9271
  • 0
  • Profile & Reviews

User Ratings (Based on 5 reviews)

Food 4.1 Value 3.5
Service 3.6 Atmosphere 4.4

Other Restaurant Info

(305) 664-9271
Major Credit Cards
Daily: 11am-10pm
Lunch, Dinner
Great Views, Outdoor Dining, Waterfront, Raw Bar, Accepts Credit Cards

User Reviews

  • Islamorada Fish Company

    Posted by DAVE R on 07/02/2014

    She Crab

    Got to have the She Crab soup. Chowder like but nobody does it like this place. Scampi and the Diabla are to die for.

  • Islamorada Fish Company

    Posted by Kevin on 04/02/2013

    The shrimp are bigger in Wisconsin.

    I asked the waitress if this was corporate owned. The food was good but just had that corporate taste and appearance. We had shrimp on both of our dinners. All I can say is that the shrimp are bigger in Wisconsin...

  • Islamorada Fish Company

    Posted by Felix C on 07/09/2012

    Exellent everything

    Just visited last weekend. I had Cracked Conch. Wife had Grouper Portofino.(sauce on the latter was worthy of dipping with bread) Both were served quickly and were fresh and tasted great. Best Grouper I ever tasted. Not smelly as is usual elsewhere. Single dessert order of Key lime pie was sufficient for two people Our server was diligent and courteous. Only quibble is the coffee is $2.69 per cup. Iced Tea is the same. More than a little expensive in my opinion.

  • Islamorada Fish Company

    Posted by Beth on 07/26/2011

    Great night

    This was mine and my husbands first time eating here and we enjoyed every bite! You can ask around to all the locals and tourists and get many different opinions on the fish co. but until you try it yourself, you will find out it is very tasty, food, drinks and atmosphere!

  • Islamorada Fish Company

    Posted by Ivan on 02/16/2009

    Beautiful place, poor staff attitude

    We visited this IFC on Sat Feb 14 around 3pm to celebrate Valentine's Day with friends and family. We were a total of 19 guests, 8 adults and 11 children. We were setup in two tables along with other tables with children, next to the bar. First, our kids were on a table where the sun was hitting pretty hard through big window that appeared to have a roll down shade like I've seen in many restaurants. We asked our waitress if she could lower the shade so it would not be so bright. She said "There's no shade" with a bad attitude and asked somebody else in our table what he wanted to drink. Then two of the mothers went over the kids table to help the waitress take the order. We asked her for a kids menu and she said coldly there weren't any printed and she would tell them what was available. She kept rolling her eyes and complained each time one kid ordered something or could not make their mind. Our children were having fun and we had ordered our drinks and food already. A manager approached the adult's table, with a bad attitude and in a nasty tone of voice demanded one of the adults needed to sit at the children's table. All of these in a tone of voice other customers could hear and finger pointing the table where our kids were located. She said other customers complained and once again in an imperative manner demanded an adult sat with the children. We told her we were customers too and she said that we were being loud in the adults table also and demanded one more time to have one of us move to the children's table. We were in shock. At this point, we advised her we will not accept her attitude and to please cancel our entire food order. We reiterated we would leave than be treated that way. She replied "OK" and walked away. Then the hospitality manager, a very nice and professional guy, came over and asked if we wanted our order to go, we declined his offer. Two of the adults in our group before leaving asked to speak to the superior. They were referred to the same hospitality manager offering us our meals to go. He tried reaching the manager over the walkie-talkie and she would not respond.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.