Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Islamorada Fish Company

  • $$$$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Seafood
  • 81532 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada FL33036 24.9144966 -80.6403999
  • (Btwn Matecumbe & Jerome Ave)
  • (305) 664-9271
  • 0


Seafood-Stuffed Mushrooms    7.95
Conch Fritters    7.95
Squid Rings    7.95
Smoked Fish Dip    7.95
Crab Cake    9.95
Spinach Con Queso    7.95
Alligator    9.95
Conch Salad    7.95
Cracked Conch    9.95
Coconut Shrimp    8.95
Fish Tacos    8.95

Homemade Soups

Cup $3.95 / Bowl $4.95

Clam Chowder white   
Conch Chowder red   


House mixed greens topped with fresh vegetables and mixed cheeses   6.95
Caesar chopped fresh romaine with dressing, croutons, and parmesan cheese   6.95
Greek mixed greens, feta cheese, greek olives, tomatoes, onions and pepperoncinis   8.95

Salad Toppers

House Caesar / Greek

Fresh Dolphin fried or grilled  15.95 17.95
Scallops (1/4-Lb.) fried or grilled  15.95 17.95
Chicken Breast fried or grilled  11.95 13.95
Shrimp Skewer grilled  16.95 18.95
Yellowfin Tuna * grilled  17.95 19.95
Florida Lobster Tail grilled   


All Sandwiches Are Served With Coleslaw And Your Choice Of Fries, Potato Salad Or Tropical Rice Pilaf.

Dolphin fried or grilled   13.95
Grouper fried or grilled   14.95
Chicken fried or grilled   9.95
Fried Cracked Conch    13.45
Islamorada Fish Sandwich (fried or grilled) grouper topped with sautéed onions and american cheese and served on a kaiser roll.   14.95
Snapper fried or grilled   12.95
Tuna *   13.95
Crab Cake    13.95
Cheeseburger *   9.95
Grouper Reuben (fried or grilled) fresh grouper topped with thousand island slaw dressing and swiss cheese and served on our grilled texas-cut rye bread.   15.95

Island Sampler

2 Crab Cakes conch fritters & alligator   13.95

Raw Bar

Shrimp Cocktail    9.95
Steamed Clams  (1/2 doz) 7.95doz 12.95
Raw Oysters  (1/2 doz) 7.95doz 12.95
Old Bay Shrimp hot or cold (1/2 lb) 8.95pound 15.95
Stone Crab Claws (seasonal). available october 15-may 15.   

Fried Baskets

Served With Coleslaw And Your Choice Of Fries, Potato Salad Or Tropical Rice Pilaf. All Fish Filets And Shrimp Can Be Fried Coconut Style.

Dolphin    18.95
Tenderized American Alligator    14.95
Shrimp    15.95
Oysters    13.95
Calamari    12.95
Sea Scallops    18.95
Clam Strips    13.95
Cracked Conch    14.95
Combo Baskets choice of any 2 above   20.95
Grouper    20.95
Crab Cakes    19.95
Whole Fried Yellowtail Snapper    

Grilled Platters

Served With Vegetable Of The Day And Your Choice Of Fries, Potato Salad Or Tropical Rice Pilaf. Options: Blackened, Teriyaki, Roasted Garlic Or Tropical BBQ

Dolphin    18.95
Sea Scallops    18.95
Combo Platter choice of 2: shrimp, scallops, or dolphin   20.95
Grouper    20.95
Shrimp Skewer  sgl 15.95dbl 20.95
Domestic Snapper    17.95
Yellowfin Tuna *   19.95
Florida Lobster Tail (Sgl / Dbl)    


All Entrées Except Stone Crab Claws Served With Vegetable Of The Day And Your Choice Of Fries, Potato Salad Or Tropical Rice Pilaf.

Dolphin Chardonnay freshly baked dolphin topped with fresh mushrooms and tomatoes in a california chardonnay sauce   22.95
Stuffed Dolphin fresh dolphin stuffed with our herb-seasoned crabmeat stuffing and garnished with a tropical mango salsa and topped with a creamy hollandaise sauce.   23.95
Stuffed Shrimp succulent shrimp stuffed with our herb-seasoned crabmeat stuffing and topped with hollandaise sauce.   21.95
Tuna Wasabi * sushi-grade yellowfin tuna seared to temperature, covered in sesame seeds & topped with our islamorada wasabi sauce.   21.95
Snapper Française fresh yellowtail snapper filet dipped in a seasoned egg batter and sautéed to golden brown and topped with a lemon butter sauce.   21.95
Stuffed Florida Lobster (Seasonal) whole fresh florida lobster stuffed with shrimp, scallops and our herb seasoned crabmeat stuffing.   
Stone Crab Claws (Seasonal) fresh medium or large stone crab claws. served hot or cold. served with coleslaw.   
Grouper Portofino fresh grouper, blackened and topped with key west shrimp in a brandied lobster cream sauce.   22.95

Dry Land

All Entrées Served With Vegetable Of The Day And Your Choice Of Fries, Potato Salad Or Tropical Rice Pilaf.

Strip Steak * 12oz. aged black angus center cut sirloin.   22.95
St. Louis Ribs full slab of tender ribs smothered in islamorada's own tropical bbq sauce.   19.95
Top Sirloin * usda choice   15.95
Chicken Piccata chicken breast filets dusted in flour and sautéed golden brown. topped with a lemon caper sauce.   14.95


Key West Pasta key west shrimp tossed in a rich creamy lobster sauce and plated on a bed of linguine   18.95
Chicken Alfredo blackened chicken tossed in a creamy alfredo sauce and plated on a bed of linguine   14.95
Pasta Morada our house special features large shrimp, mussels, clams and lobster tossed in a fresh clam sauce. served over linguine with a touch of marinara sauce   21.95


Potato Salad    2.25
Sautéed Mushrooms    2.25
Sautéed Onions    2.25
Side Garden/Caesar    4.50
Vegetable Of The Day    2.50
Coleslaw    2.25
Rice    2.25
Feta Cheese    1.95
Small Greek    5.95
Basket Of Fries    2.95
* This Food Item May Be Served To Your Cooking Preference. Items Served Raw Or Medium May Be Undercooked. Consuming Raw Or Undercooked Animal Products Such As Meats, Poultry, Seafood, Shellfish Or Eggs Can Increase Your Risk Of Foodborne Illness,
Islamorada Fish Company
81532 Overseas Hwy
Btwn Matecumbe & Jerome Ave
(305) 664-9271
© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.