Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Island Fish Co

  • $$$$$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Seafood, American (Traditional), Steakhouses
  • 12648 Overseas Hwy, Marathon FL33050 24.733236 -81.018885
  • (MM 54 bayside)
  • (305) 743-4191
  • 0

Raw Bar

Cold Water Oysters selections change daily   2.50
add moscow   .75
Gulf Oysters  (1/2 dozen) 5.70dozen 9.95
Clams   (1/2 dozen) 5.95dozen 10.95
steamed add   1.00
Baked Key Lime Garlic Oysters topped with key lime garlic butter   8.95
Oyster Rockefeller baked with spinach, parmesan cheese and pernod liquor   9.95
Baked BBQ Oysters topped with bacon and parmesan cheese   8.95
The Island's Oyster Combo two each our baked oysters   8.95
Shrimp Cocktail    10.50
Peel And Eat Shrimp  (1/2 lb) 10.95 lb 19.95
Beer Steamed Shrimp  (1/2 lb) 11.95 lb 21.95
Oyster Moscow (6) topped with sour cream horseradish and caviar   10.95
Seafood Tower 1/2 dz. oysters and clams, 1 lb of peel and eat shrimp and stone crabs   49.95
Steamers little neck clams with drawn butter   10.95
Clams Casino topped with onions, green peppers, garlic and smoked bacon   10.95
Florida Stone Crab Claws 1/2 lb or full lb with key lime mustard sauce   


Conch Fritters    8.95
Fried Calamari    9.95
Mango Crab Cakes    10.95
Tuna Tataki    12.95
Buffalo Shrimp    11.95
Spinach Crab Dip    10.95
Seafood Boats    11.95
Conch Ceviche    13.95
Lobster Egg Rolls    9.95
Smoked Fish Dip    8.95

South Of The Border

Cheese Quesadilla    6.95
Chicken Quesadilla    9.95
Seafood Quesadilla    12.95
Nachos    7.95
Macho Nachos    11.95
Key West Grilled Shrimp Tacos    13.95

From The Garden

With Your Choice Balsamic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Thousand Island, Raspberry Vinaigrette or Bleu Cheese $0.50 Extra

House Salad a medley of garden fresh veggies and crisp romaine   5.95
Chef Salad the island's version of the classic. our large house salad with grilled chicken, shrimp, crab and cheese   13.95
Island Spinach Salad topped with mushroom, hand boiled egg, croutons and bacon with hot bacon raspberry vinaigrette   13.95
add to any salads fried oysters   5.95
chicken   2.95
grilled or fried shrimp   6.95
grilled catch   8.95
1/2 grilled lobster tail   9.95
Caesar    7.95
Seared Tuna Carpaccio sliced thin over mixed greens with pineapple, bleu cheese, tomatoes, artichokes, cucumbers, onion, pickled ginger, wasabi, seaweed salad and ginger teriyaki vinaigrette   21.95
Cajun Chicken Salad cajun spiced fried chicken breast over a large house salad with shredded cheese   10.95


All Wraps Served With Chef's Rice And Black Beans

Fried Dolphin with tomatoes, onions, lettuce and tartar sauce   12.95
Pistachio Chicken with spring mix diced tomatoes and honey mustard   11.95
Mexicano Chicken with rice, black beans scallion, tomato, jack cheese sour cream and guacamole   11.95
Grilled Seafood shrimp and scallops, spinach onion and sauce verde   12.95
Grilled Chicken Caesar spring mix, tomato, cheddar & jack cheese with dressing   11.95

House Specialties

Island Steak 7 oz. sirloin strip served with vine ripe tomatoes and chef's rice   17.95
B.B.Q. Shrimp wrapped in smoked bacon topped with monterey pack and cheese served with chef's rice and veggies   17.95
Stuffed Shrimp stuffed with mango crabmeat stuffing topped with key lime mustard sauce served with chef's rice & black beans   19.95
Caribbean Special pan seared grouper with pineapple salsa, black beans and chef's rice   20.95
Grilled, Dolphin Pico De Gallo served over black beans and chef's rice   18.95
Key West Shrimp Tempura dipped in tempura batter, fried served with chef's rice, veggies and jalapeno chutney   20.95
Coconut Fried Shrimp served with toasted coconut, chef's rice, veggie and jalapeno chutney   18.95
1/2 Roasted Lemon Pepper Chicken with island rice & black beans   16.95

Island Platters

All Island Platters Served With Fresh Fries And Coleslaw

Fried Select Oysters    12.95
Fried Pink Gold Shrimp    13.95
Fried Dolphin    12.95
Fried Grouper    14.95
Fried Clam Strips    8.95
Chicken Wings one dozen choice of mild, medium or hot   8.95


Cup $3.95 / Bowl $4.95

Conch Chowder island style   
Island She Krab creamy with sauteed onions, celery scallions and sherry   
Soup Of The Day made fresh daily   


Served With Coleslaw, Pickle And Chips. Add French Fries For $1.75

Fried Oyster Po Boy on a toasted hoagie roll with remoulade sauce, lettuce, tomato and banana peppers   10.95
Grilled, Fried Or Blackened Catch Sandwich fresh catch changed daily served on kaiser burn with lettuce, tomato, red onion, & tarter sauce   12.95
Grilled Mojo Chicken Breast    8.95
The Island Cheese Steak thinly sliced sirloin topped with sauteed peppers, mushrooms onions and cheddar cheese   10.95
Big City Red Hot Dog plain   6.95
sauerkraut or chili add with fries   1.00
French Dip roast beef on fresh bread with creamy horseradish sauce and au jus   11.95
Angus Beef Sirloin Burger add american, swiss monterey jack, blue cheese, bacon   7.95
grilled onions or sauteed mushroom each   .75
Crispy Lobster Sandwich with remoulade sauce, spring mix, tomato, banana peppers   13.95
Veggie Burger    6.95

The Island Steaks

Surf And Turf 8 oz. grilled filet and 6 oz lobster tail served with bearnaise sauce, drawn butter, new potatoes and sauteed vegetables   42.95
Filet Mignon 8 oz. filet frilled and accompanied with béarnaise sauce served with new potatoes and sauteed vegetables   33.95
New York Strip the big brother to the island steak 12 oz trimmed and grilled to perfection, served with new potatoes and sauteed vegetables   29.95
Add Sauteed Mushrooms To Any Of The Above $1.50

Fresh Catch

Served With Chef's Rice And Sauteed Vegetables

Grilled for the purist with lemon   23.95
Pan Fried lightly dusted in flour and sauteed with sherry, lemon and butter   23.95
Blackened cajun seasoned   23.95
Broiled cooked with sherry and fresh lemon   23.95
Francaise dipped in a light egg wash and sautéed in white wine and butter   23.95
Almondine broiled in sherry and lemon topped with roasted almond slices   23.95
Florida Lobster Tail from the local waters, broiled or francaise style   29.95


Pasta Basilico vine ripe tomatoes, garlic olive oil, parmesan cheese and fresh basil over linguini   13.95
with chicken   16.95
Clams Or Mussel Marinara with our homemade marinara sauce served over linguini   17.95
White Clam Linguini    17.95
Shell Fish Lovers Pasta a saute of fresh shrimp, clams mussels and scallops finished with fresh cream, lemon, sherry, fresh herbs and butter served over linguini   22.95
Key West Shrimp Fra Diavolo cajun spiced sautéed shrimp over linguini tossed with a sassy kicked up marinara sauce   22.95
Key West Shrimp Diane dusted in cajun seasoning sauteed with mushrooms, scallions, garlic white wine and herb butter served over linguini   22.95
Key West Shrimp Scampi sauteed with white wine butter, lemon, scallions and garlic tossed with linguini   22.95
Pasta Steak And Fresh Catch Diane Include Salad


French Fries    2.50
Onion Rings    3.95
Tator Tots    2.50
Garlic Bread    2.25
Black Beans And Chef's Rice    3.95
Fried Plantains    3.95
Vegetable Medley    2.95
New Potatoes    2.50

Children's Menu

Hamburger And Fries    5.50
Cheeseburger And Fries    5.75
Grilled Cheese And Fries    5.25
Pasta And Sauce    5.50
Fish Fingers And Fries    6.50
Chicken Fingers And Fries    5.75
Hot Dog And Fries    5.75
Children’s Menu Is For Kids 10 & Under

Sweet Endings

Home Made Key Lime Pie    4.50
Flash Fried Key Lime Pie    5.50
Three Chocolate Mousse Cake    5.50
Fresh Baked Four Berry Pie    4.50
Strawberry Cheesecake    5.50
Flash Fried Cheesecake    5.50
Island Fish Co
12648 Overseas Hwy
MM 54 bayside
(305) 743-4191
© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.