Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by Marti and Nestor on 11/30/2011
Found this hidden gem one day before going food shopping! I never go on an empty stomach! Had the Italian Hoagie and it was stock full of delicious Italian cuts of meats and a simple delicious sauce. I think the secret is in their understanding of true Italian food. I have been a regular and will try the Tuesday night pizza! Bravo!
Posted by Scott on 11/08/2011
Best pizza around and their large cheese pizza on Tuesday can't be beat. Family owned and everyone is so friendly. Everything is made from scratch and the pizza dough is delicious. Their other dishes are also very good and you must try the garlic knots.
Posted by Pete on 10/22/2011
I am very picky about pizza, being from NY but Jay's does it well. way above any other pizza place I have found in the area. Thanks Jay's
Posted by Jessica on 05/10/2011
Hands down this is the best pizza I've ever tasted and the list doesn't stop there. you should try their gourmet dishes and the pasta sauce!! Food is outstanding!
Posted by Johnnie on 02/20/2011
Great pizza right around the corner! We live in Andros Isle and can walk right to shop. The food and service are wonderful. Make sure to order the garlic knots - they are the mmm mmm good!
Posted by Neph Rod on 11/09/2010
I haven't eaten much on the menu but what I have ordered was good but the pizza is what causes me to write about this hidden treasure. I'm from Brooklyn and hate seeing "New York Style Pizza" advertised. I'm usually let down by this false claim. This place doesn't say it but should. Finally an awesome pizza joint. For those of you who love pizza, you need to at the very least check it out. Complimenting the pizza is the pizza special they have every Tuesday. I love this place and will be a customer for life!
Posted by Patrick Munley on 02/20/2010
My wife and I moved to this area about 6 years ago. Until we found this pizza joint, we were forced to eat frozen pizzas. The place is sorta hidden next to Publix, but definitely stands out when it comes to their pizzas.