Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

New Island Grill (CLOSED)

  • $$$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Bar Food, Seafood, Pizza
  • 31251 Avenue A, Big Pine Key FL33043 24.6696329 -81.3441744
  • (At 2nd St)
  • click map to interact
  • (305) 872-3022
  • 0


Chicken Wings served with bleu cheese or ranch dressing and celery with your choice of sauce: hot, medium, mild bbq, jerk or garlic(10pcs) 8.25 (20pcs) 15.25 (30pcs) 22.25
Fresh Key West Pink Shrimp  (1/2 lb) 9.95 (1lb) 18.95
Buffalo Shrimp    10.95
Buffalo Conch    11.95
Shrimp Tempura    9.95
Cracked Conch    10.95
Homemade Conch Fritter deep fried with cocktail sauce or tartar   8.95
Sesame Seared Tuna yellowfin tuna encrusted with sesame seed, seared and served with a ginger soy vinaigrette, wasabi, and seaweed salad.   13.95

Soups & Salads

Side Salad    3.95
House Salad    7.95
"Grilled Salads" with chicken   9.95
with shrimp   12.95
Caesar Salad fresh romaine lettuce tossed with parmesan and croutons   8.95
add chicken   2.00
add shrimp   4.00
Homemade Soup Of The Day Or Conch Chowder  cup 4.25 bowl 5.25

Salad Dressings

Bleu Cheese    
Honey Mustard    
Thousand Island Or Balsamic Vinaigrette    

Hot Sandwiches

All Burgers Hot Sandwiches And Baskets Are Served With Coleslaw And French Fries

Mahi Mahi Sandwich fresh mahi grilled, fried or blackened   10.95
Mahi Mahi Reuben grilled mahi mahi, swiss cheese, cole slaw and thousand island dressing served on grilled rye bread   11.95
Chicken Sandwich grilled, blackened or fried   9.95
Rhody Chicken Sandwich chicken breast served on a sub roll with bacon, bbq sauce, served onions and cheddar cheese   10.95
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich breaded chicken breast topped with our buffalo sauce and bleu cheese   10.95
Philly Cheese Steak premium philly beef served with peppers, onions and american cheese   10.95
French Dip roast beef, grilled onions and provolone cheese served hot on a sub roll with au jus   10.95

Homemade Burgers

100% USDA Choice Beef Dressed With Lettuce, Tomato And Onion

Burger    9.50
Cheese Burger    9.95
Black & Bleu    10.50
Bacon Cheeseburger    10.50


Chicken Tender Basket white meat strips of chicken, breaded and deep fried   9.95
Buffalo Chicken Tenders chicken tenders tossed in our own buffalo sauce, served with blue cheese   9.95
Jumbo Shrimp Basket fresh key west pink shrimp lightly breaded and deep fried   12.95
Buffalo Shrimp Basket our jumbo fried shrimp tossed in buffalo sauce with cheese   13.95
Rib Basket 1/2 rack of ribs served with fries and slaw   15.95
Fresh Local Fish Basket our fresh catch of the day, lightly breaded and deep fried   12.95

House Pizza

Hand Tossed 12" Cheese    9.95

House Pizza Toppings $0.75 Each

Green Peppers    
Banana Peppers    
Black Olives    

Beverages - Refreshments

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Root Beer, Ginger Ale, Mountain Dew, Dr.Pepper, Pink Lemonade    2.00
Coffee, Fresh Brewed Iced Tea    2.00
Juices orange, pineapple, cranberry, grapefruit   2.00

House Wines By The Glass $5

From Copper Ridge chardonnay, white zinfandel, merlot, cabernet sauvignon   
Barefoot Pinot Grigio    

Beer - On Tap

Bud, Bud Light, Coors Light, Miller Light, Yuengling    3.00
Blue Moon, Sierra Nevada, Key West Sunset Ale    4.00
Samuel Adams Seasonal    4.50

Beer - Bottles

Pabst Blue Ribbon    2.00
Bud, Bud Light, Coors Light, Miller Light, O'Doul's    3.00
Amstel Light, Heineken, Corona Light, Red Stripe, Shock Top, Michelob Ultra & Stella Artois    4.00

Dinner Specials

Every Monday meatloaf, mashed potatoes & gravy   
Every Tuesday italian night   
Every Friday prime rib night   
New Island Grill
31251 Avenue A
At 2nd St
(305) 872-3022
© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.