Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Rusty Anchor

  • $$$$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Seafood
  • 5501 5th Ave, Key West FL33040 24.568661 -81.7386806
  • (At Shrimp Rd)
  • (305) 294-5369
  • 0


Conch Fritters the best fritters in town with lots of conch (1/2 doz) 5.75(full doz) 8.75
Calamari Rings hand cut squid breaded and deep fried plain or italian served with homemade cocktail sauce   7.95
Smoked Fish Dip fresh caught fish, smoked and blended into a creamy dip   6.50
Peel And Eat Shrimp local shrimp steamed daily with herbs and spices served hot or cold with drawn butter   9.95
Buffalo Style Chicken Wings chicken wings spiced with cayenne & sweetened with honey   8.95
Stone Crab Claws fresh seasonal stone crabs served with a garden salad and honey mustard   
Red Conch Chowder tomato base homemade conch chowder cup 4.75bowl 5.75
Seared Tuna lightly seared tuna with sesame seeds served with wasabi and soy sauce   12.95


Rusty's Garden Salad    3.95
shrimp   9.95
chicken   8.95
Have Your Fish , Shrimp Or Chicken Grilled, Blackened, Lemon Peppered Or Fried. Homemade Salad Dressings: Ranch, Balsamic, 1000 Island, Italian, Blue Cheese.



11am-5pm. Your Choice: American, Cheddar, Swiss, Provolone Or Pepper Jack Served With Homemade Cole Slaw, French Fries And Lettuce, Tomato & Onion.

Rusty's Fish on cuban bread, fried, grilled, blackened or lemon peppered   
Fried Conch on cuban bread, sweet tender white conch seasoned and fried   12.95
Fish Reuben blackened fish with swiss cheese, sauerkraut and 1000 island dressing on rye bread   10.95
Original Cuban Mix pork, ham, cheese, pickles, lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo & mustard   8.75
Ham And Cheese on cuban bread, white, wheat or rye served hot or cold   6.95
Chicken on cuban bread, fried, buffalo, grilled or blackened   9.95
Delmonico Steak on cuban bread, with grilled onions   11.95
Deep Blue Burger 10oz of angus beef with cheese and bacon   9.50
The Gorilla Burger 10oz of angus beef with cheese and bacon   9.50
Sliced Roast Beef sliced juicy rib eye on cuban bread, au jus & creamy horseradish sauce   9.95

Sandwiches - Rusty Anchor Baskets

Baskets Served With French Fries & Homemade Cole Slaw

Fresh Fish fried, grilled, blackened or lemon peppered   
Clam Strip Fried    7.50
Shrimp Fried Or Buffalo    9.95
Chicken Tenders Fried Or Buffalo    7.95

Additional Sides $1.50

Black Beans    
Rice Or Cole Slaw    
French Fries    




Local Fish Of The Day have your fish prepared pan fried, grilled, blackened, lemon peppered, broiled or deep fried   
Florida Keys Spiny Lobster fresh tender lobster, broiled or fried served with drawn butter   
Rusty's Famous Conch Steak sweet tender white conch seasoned and fried   19.95
Fried Captains Platter conch fritters, fried shrimp, fried fish, calamari rings and fried clams served with french fries only   24.95
Key West Pink Shrimp florida keys pink shrimp, fried, buffalo or sauteed   18.95
1lb Steamed Pink Shrimp peel and eat served hot or cold with drawn butter   17.50
Steak Delmonico hand cut 16oz rib eye grilled to order   21.95
BBQ Baby Back Ribs full rack of barbecued ribs   17.95
All Dinners Come With Choice Of Two Sides.(Additional Sides Extra Charge $1.50 Per Item) Black Beans, Rice, Sweet Potato, Plain Or Loaded Baked Potato, French Fries, Cole Slaw Or Vegetable


Your Choice: American, Cheddar, Swiss, Provolone Or Pepper Jack Served With Homemade Cole Slaw, French Fries, Lettuce, Tomato & Onion

Rusty's Fish on cuban bread fried, grilled, blackened or lemon peppered   
The Gorilla Burger 10oz of angus beef, includes your choice of cheese, blue cheese, bacon & grilled onion   10.95
Chicken on cuban bread fried, buffalo, grilled or blackened   9.95



Soup Of The Day    
Locally Caught Fish the rusty anchor restaurant and seafood market est.1983. home of the florida keys freshest seafood. rusty anchor receives fresh local seafood daily. our in house seafood market is available for retail and wholesale or next day shipping.   
Seared Tuna lightly seared tuna with sesame seed served with wasabi and soy sauce   
tuna appetizer   12.95
tuna dinner   18.95
Sea Scallops large excellent sea scallops sauteed, broiled or fried   
Chef's Pasta Special    

Wednesday Night

Prime Rib Roast center cut prime rib roast, prepared with rosemary and slow-roasted to perfection   
queen cut   22.95
king cut   24.95



Key Lime Pie homemade key lime pie fresh from the keys to your table   4.00
Fudge Dark Chocolate Pie dark thick mousse with a toffee center served with vanilla ice cream & whipped cream   5.50
Supreme Cheese Cake vanilla cheese cake served with strawberries or caramel topping & whipped cream   5.00
Apple Pie A La Mode warm apple pie with vanilla ice cream drizzled with caramel   4.50
Pecan Pie traditional pecan pie with vanilla ice cream & whipped cream   4.50
Vanilla Or Chocolate Ice Cream topped with your choice of chocolate syrup or strawberries & whipped cream   3.50

Kids Menu

Kids 12 And Under


Mini Shrimp & Fries Basked    6.95
Mini Fish Bites & Fries Basket    5.95
Chicken Fingers & Fries    5.00
Cheese Burger & Fries    5.95
Grilled Cheese & Fires    4.95
Ham And Cheese Sandwich & Fries    5.50
Black Beans & Rice    1.50

Drink Included With Meal

Apple Juice    


Chocolate Or Vanilla Ice Cream    2.50



Happy Hour 4-7

Coffee Drinks

Italian Coffee amaretto & coffee   6.50
Coffee Royale baileys & brandy   7.50
Keoki Coffee kaluha & brandy   7.50
Plain Shot Of Frangelico    7.00
Espresso    2.00
Cappuccino    4.00
Jamaican Coffee tia maria & rum   7.50
Swiss Coffee peppermint schnapps & creme de cacao   6.50
Hot Fisherman frangelico, baileys & coffee   8.50

Imports $5

Becks Dark    
Corona Light    
Dos Xx    
Kalik Gold    
Red Stripe    

Premium $4.50

Blue Moon    
Sam Adams    

Beer $4

Bud Light    
Coors Light    
Miller Lite    
Michelob Ultra    

Special Drinks

Dirty Boat Martini grey goose, queen olives   7.50
Espresso Martini van gogh espresso vodka, dash of real espresso & kahlua   7.00
Flying Cosmo Martini citrus vodka, triple sec, & splash cranberry &lime juice   7.00
Peach Martini absolute peach vodka, peach puree, peach schnapps with a sugar rim   7.00
Salted Carmel Martini stoli salted caramel vodka & apple juice, rimed with cinnamon sugar   7.00
Vanilla Martini absolute vanila vodka dash of tuaca   7.00
Ocean Dream absolute vodka, coconut rum & a splash of pineapple   7.00
Wild Cherry Lemonade stoli wild cherry vodka, cranberry, pink lemonade & splash of sierra mist   6.50
Zing Mary ketel one vodka and zing zang bloody mary mix   8.00
Dark & Stormy coruba dark rum & ginger beer   6.50
Mango Mangrove anejo rum, amaretto, mango & orange juice   7.00
Pain Killer myers's rum, coconut cream, pineapple & orange juice, frozen or rocks   7.50
Rum Smuggler bacardi rum light & dark, banana liquor, black brandy & fruit juice   7.50
Rusty's Rum Punch bacardi rum light & dark & fruit juice   6.50
Cuba Libre don quba rum & coke   6.00
Stock Island Tea vodka, rum, gin, tequila, triple sec, sour & coke   7.00
Margarita gold   7.50
blue   7.00
Strawberry Daiquiri    6.50
Pina Colada    6.50

Flipflop Wine By Glass $6

Proceeds Help Buy Shoes For Souls That Are In Need

Sauvignon Blanc    
Pinot Grigio    
Pink Moscato    
Pinot Noir    
House Whit Zinfandel    


Rusty Anchor
5501 5th Ave
At Shrimp Rd
(305) 294-5369
or (305) 296-2893
© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.