Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Upper Crust Pizza

  • $$
  • Italian, Pizza
  • 101611 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo 33037 25.11699 -80.41999
  • (Btwn Michele Dr & Samson Rd)
  • click map to interact
  • 0

Appetizers/Side Orders

Homemade Garlic Bread     3.50
Homemade Garlic Bread with cheese    4.25
Homemade Whole Wheat Garlic Bread     2.75
Homemade Whole Wheat Garlic Bread with cheese    3.75
Homemade Chef's Garlic Rolls    (6) 3.99 (4) 2.99 (12) 4.99
Meatballs     3.95
Meatballs with cheese    4.95
Buffalo Shrimp    (7) 11.99
Fried Mushrooms     6.99
Chicken Wings hot, mild, medium, bbq.   (12) 7.99 (6) 4.99
Chicken Wings for teriyaki or honey garlic   (add) 1.00
Chicken Fingers with bbq sauce or honey-mustard    6.99
Soup Of The Day homemade!    3.95
Side Of Spaghetti     3.75
Side Of Fettuccini Alfredo     4.25
French Fries    (bucket) 2.75
French Fries with cheese    3.95
Pizza Bread with marinara sauce    3.95
Pizza Bread with alfredo sauce    4.95
Mozzarella Stix    (5) 7.50
Poppers cheddar   (5) 7.50
Broccoli Bites with raspberry sauce    7.99
Homemade Onion Rings     4.99


All Salads Served With House Italian Dressing. For Bleu Cheese, Honey-Mustard, French, Thousand Island, Ranch, Or Creamy Italian Dressing Add $0.50 For Small; Add $1 For Large. Croutons Add $0.50, Extra Dressing: $050 Each. Our Ingredients Are The Freshes

House Salad    sm 4.50 lg 7.50
Cheese Salad swiss, american and mozzarella cheeses with avocado, mushroom and artichoke hearts and fresh veggies    9.95
Chicken Salad cheese & an assortment of fresh veggies    9.95
Chicken Salad add for blackened chicken    3.00
Chef's Salad ham, turkey, swiss and american cheeses with lots of fresh veggies    9.95
Antipasta salami, ham, pepperoni, pepperoncini mozzarella cheese and lots of veggies.    9.95
Tuna Salad     9.95


Dinners Include Homemade Garlic Bread And Salad With House Italian Dressing

Homemade Meat Lasagna     12.95
Homemade Vegetarian Lasagna with ricotta cheese and fresh veggies    12.50
Spaghetti choice of: meatball, meat sauce, sausage or mushroom    10.95
Spaghetti Bolognese house special! meat sauce with green peppers and onion    12.95
Spaghetti And Veggies with veggies, marinara sauce & melted cheese    11.50
Fettuccini Alfredo with homemade alfredo sauce    10.95
Fettuccini Alfredo with mushroom    11.95
Fettuccini Alfredo with chicken    12.95
Fettuccini Alfredo with blackened chicken    14.95
Fettuccini Alfredo with chicken & broccoli    12.95
Fettuccini Alfredo with ham, chicken and pineapple    13.95
Fettuccini Alfredo with shrimp    17.95
Seafood Alfredo with lobster meat, crab meat and scallops    17.95
Shrimp Scampi     16.95
Pasta Primavera fresh veggies over pasta with olive oil & garlic    11.95
Pasta Primavera with chicken    14.95
Pasta Primavera with shrimp    17.95
Pasta Primavera for marinara or creamy alfredo sauce   add 2.00
Chicken Florentine with spinach, garlic and alfredo sauce    13.95
Chicken Breast Parmigiano     14.95
Eggplant Parmigiano     11.95
Meat Ravioli covered in melted cheese    11.95
Cheese And Spinach Ravioli with your choice of: alfredo or pink sauce    11.95
Crab & Lobster Ravioli In Alfredo Sauce     13.95
Stuffed Shells     11.95
Stuffed Green Pepper with mushrooms and meatballs, topped with cheese    12.95

House Specialty Pizzas

12" / 14" / 16"

House Deluxe pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, green pepper, onion, black olives, extra cheese and extra sauce    19.00  17.00  14.00
Meat Lovers pepperoni, ham, sausage, salami, meatball, extra sauce & extra cheese    17.00  19.00  14.00
Meat Lovers add bacon    2.00
Vegetarian mushrooms, onion, green pepper, black olives, veggie mix, tomato, garlic, extra cheese and extra sauce    14.00  17.00  19.00
Seafood crab meat, lobster meat, scallops with butter and fresh garlic in creamy alfredo sauce    26.00  24.00  22.00
Shrimp shrimp with your choice of tomato or creamy alfredo sauce    23.00  25.00  27.00
Shrimp add for pink sauce    1.00
Chicken & Broccoli with creamy alfredo sauce    20.00  25.00  23.00
BBQ Chicken chicken, bacon, onion, bbq sauce and extra cheese    18.00  16.00  20.00
Buffalo Chicken chicken, onion, hot & spicy sauce and extra cheese    20.00  18.00  16.00
Chicken Fajita chicken, sautéed onion, green pepper, mushrooms, garlic, jalapeños, extra cheese & extra sauce    24.00  22.00  18.00
Steak Fajita steak, sautéed onion, green pepper, mushrooms, garlic, jalapeños, extra cheese & extra sauce    19.00  25.00  23.00
Hawaiian ham, pineapple, extra cheese & extra sauce    13.00  15.00  17.00
White with ricotta cheese & mozzarella cheese    11.00  15.00  13.00
Alfredo with alfredo sauce & mozzarella cheese    16.00  14.00  12.00

Build Your Own Pizza

Your Choice Of Regular Or Thin Crust

1 Slice Cheese    deluxe 3.95  2.25
1 Slice Cheese each extra topping on slice add    0.50
12" Sauce & Cheese     9.00
12" Sauce & Cheese each additional topping    1.00
14" Sauce & Cheese     11.00
14" Sauce & Cheese each additional topping    1.25
16" Sauce & Cheese     13.00
16" Sauce & Cheese each additional topping    1.50


Black Olives   
Veggie Mix   
Green Pepper   
Whole Tomato   
Extra Sauce   

Specialty Toppings

Ask About Our Calzone & Stromboli.

Extra Cheese     2.00
Ricotta Cheese     2.00
Alfredo Sauce     3.00
Pink Sauce     4.00
Anchovy     2.00
Artichokes     3.00
Bacon     2.00
Sautéed Onions     2.00
Chicken     4.00
Blackened Chicken     5.00
BBQ Chicken     5.00
Steak     5.00


All Subs Served Hot On Our Fresh Homemade Buns. Add A Side Of Fries Or Chips For $1.50. Subs Are Served Without Onions. If You Would Like Onions, Please Request Them.

Gondola (italian mix) ham, salami, mozzarella, lettuce and herb oil    6.75
Hoagie (american mix) ham, salami, american, swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo    6.75
Turkey Sub lettuce, tomato, mayo and mozzarella cheese    6.75
Cold Tuna Sub tuna salad, american cheese, lettuce, tomato    6.75
Meatball Sub with sauce and cheese    7.25
Steak Sub sauteed onion, mushroom, cheese    7.25
Sausage Sub grilled mushrooms, green peppers, tomato sauce and cheese    7.25
Chicken Parmigiano Sub with tomato sauce and cheese    7.50
BBQ Chicken Sub chicken, bbq sauce, lettuce, american cheese and mayo    7.50
Chicken Teriyaki Sub chicken, teriyaki sauce, lettuce, tomato, mayo and mozzarella cheese    7.50
Blackened Chicken Sub blackened chicken, lettuce, tomato, mayo and mozzarella cheese    7.50
Chicken Finger Sub lettuce, tomato, honey mustard, chicken fingers    7.50
Hawaiian Sub bbq chicken, pineapple and swiss cheese    7.75
Eggplant Sub tomato sauce and cheese    7.25
Veggie Sub 1 lettuce, tomato, mayo, herb oil, broccoli, cauliflower and carrot, topped with swiss, american and mozzarella cheese    6.95
Veggie Sub 2 lettuce, tomato, mayo, herb oil, avocado, mushrooms, black olives, topped with swiss, american and mozzarella cheese    6.95

Whole Wheat Sandwiches $6.50

Served On Our Fresh, Homemade Whole Wheat Bread. Add A Side Of Fries Or Chips For $1.50.

Turkey Melt turkey, mayo, tomato, and mozzarella cheese  
Tuna Melt tuna salad, mayo, tomato, swiss and american cheese  
Veggie Melt mushroom, veggie mix ,mayo, swiss and mozzarella cheese  


Homemade Key Lime Pie    (whole pie) 15.95 slice 4.95
Ice Cream vanilla, strawberry or chocolate dish    4.50
Homemade Tiramisu    slice 5.95

Soft Drinks - Fountain $2.50

By The Glass Free Refills

Diet Pepsi   
Dr. Pepper   
Sierra Mist   
Root Beer   
Club Soda   
Raspberry Tea   

Soft Drinks - Cans

Coke, Diet Coke, Sunkist, Mountain Dew     1.50
Lemonade     2.70
Fresh Brewed Iced Tea free refills   gl 1.95
Coffee, Decaf, Tea, free refills    1.95
Milk    gl 2.50
Chocolate Milk    gl 2.95
Orange Juice    gl 2.95
Cappuccino     3.95
Espresso     2.75
Bottled Water     1.95

Milk Shake $5.50



Draft Beers

(12oz) Glass / Pitcher Ask About Our Other Selections Of Draft Beer

Miller Lite, Budweiser, Amberbock,     2.75  10.95
Yuengling     3.25  13.95
Pilsner Urquell    (lg gl) 5.95 pitcher 17.95

Bottles Beers

Budweiser     3.50
Bud Light     3.50
Miller Lite     3.50
Coors Light     3.50
Michelob Ultra Light     3.50
O'Doul's     3.50
Heineken, Corona     4.75

Homemade Sangria

With Fresh Fruit    (pitcher) 22.95


Upper Crust Pizza
101611 Overseas Hwy
Btwn Michele Dr & Samson Rd
© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.